Taqueria by El Prieto NYC

About

Located at 139 W 28th St in the heart of Chelsea, Taqueria by El Prieto has quickly become a go-to destination for those seeking authentic Mexican street food in New York City. With a strong 4.8-star rating from over 1,400 reviews, this compact, no-frills eatery brings a taste of the West Coast to the East Coast. The menu features a variety of traditional staples, including carne asada, al pastor, and birria, alongside vegetarian options like mushroom and cactus tacos. Guests frequently highlight the freshness of the hand-made tortillas and the quality of the grilled proteins, which are served in generous portions that offer solid value for the neighborhood. The hallmark of the experience is the self-serve salsa bar, where diners can customize their meals with a selection of vibrant house-made salsas, pickled vegetables, and pinto beans. The atmosphere is casual and cozy, designed for quick bites or takeout, and the staff is consistently noted for being welcoming and accommodating. Whether you are stopping in for a chicken burrito, a refreshing agua fresca, or a selection of tacos, the restaurant provides a reliable, flavor-forward experience that captures the spirit of a neighborhood taqueria.

What clients say

Taqueria by El Prieto is widely praised for its authentic, flavorful Mexican street-style food and its popular self-serve salsa bar. While most customers enjoy the fresh ingredients and friendly service, some report inconsistency in food quality and limited seating space.

Opening hours

Friday

11 AM–1 AM

Monday

11 AM–1 AM

Sunday

11 AM–1 AM

Tuesday

11 AM–1 AM

Saturday

11 AM–1 AM

Thursday

11 AM–1 AM

Wednesday

11 AM–1 AM

Contact

• 139 W 28th St, New York, NY 10001
• (212) 256-0098
• taqueriabyelprietonyc.com